How reviewing works
- Invitation. The editors email you the manuscript’s title, journal and abstract, and ask whether you will review it.
- Accept or decline from your reviewer dashboard. If you can’t review it, please decline quickly so the editors can ask someone else.
- Read the manuscript. Download it from your dashboard. It reaches you without the authors’ names.
- Send your review within 14 days of accepting: your report as a Word file, your recommendation, and, if you like, a note to the editors.
- The editors decide, using your review. Your dashboard shows what happened to the manuscript.
Before you accept
Accept an invitation only if:
- the manuscript is within your field of expertise;
- you can give it a careful, critical reading within 14 days;
- you have no conflict of interest.
Conflicts of interest
A conflict of interest arises when a financial tie, a personal relationship or your own competing work could affect, or seem to affect, your judgement. If you have any such conflict, decline the invitation and tell the editors why.
Confidentiality
The manuscript is confidential. Don’t share it or discuss it with anyone, during or after the review, without the editors’ permission. Don’t use its unpublished data, ideas or findings in your own work, or to anyone’s advantage or disadvantage.
Fairness
Judge the work, not the authors. Your review should not be influenced by where the authors come from, their institution, religion, politics, gender, race or nationality, or by views the manuscript expresses that you don’t share.
Writing your report
Be honest, specific and constructive: the authors should be able to act on what you write. Assess:
- originality: whether the question is new and significant;
- method: the design, data, analysis and whether the conclusions follow from them;
- clarity: structure, language, figures and tables;
- completeness: whether it follows the guide for authors, cites the relevant work, and has any ethical approvals it needs.
Send the report as a Word file (.doc or .docx, up to 10 MB): either the manuscript with your comments in it, or a separate report. Leave your name out of the file, so the review stays anonymous.
The note to the editors is optional, and the authors don’t see it. Use it for anything the editors should know that isn’t for the authors.
Your recommendation
Choose one of the four, and make sure your report explains why:
- Publish as it isThe manuscript can be published without changes.
- Minor correctionsSmall changes are needed: wording, presentation, figures or references.
- Major correctionsSubstantial changes are needed to the method, analysis or argument before it can be considered again.
- Don’t publishSerious problems with originality, method or validity that revision can’t fix.
The editors make the decision, using every review they receive.
If you need more time
If something delays you after accepting, email support@oasisjournals.org as soon as you can, with the manuscript reference, to ask for more time or to hand the review back.
Further reading
Not a reviewer yet? Offer to review: tell the editors about your field and send your CV.